Sources: Idaho victim Xana Kernodle was killed last and fought back | Banfield
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 13 окт 2024
- Sources exclusively revealed to NewsNation's "Banfield" that Idaho victim Xana Kernodle was killed last, and she apparently fought back.
#IdahoFour #xanakernodle #Banfield
On "Banfield," big-name celebrities, newsmakers and public figures join Ashleigh for a unique opportunity to sit down and talk. No debates. No shouting over each other. A conversation. Weeknights at 10pm/9C.
NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all America.
More from NewsNation: www.newsnation...
Get our app: trib.al/TBXgYpp
Find us on cable: trib.al/YDOpGyG
How to watch on TV or streaming: trib.al/Vu0Ikij
The amount of terror and horror Xana would have experienced is unbelievably upsetting
Truly
No different than what Maddie and Kaylee felt.
yes agree
@@citizendame6329 they were asleep
@@TR-jc8pc no they weren't. Dylan, directly below Maddie and Kaylee, said she heard Kaylle say "someone's here". They were in bed most likely but not fast asleep. They were found in bed, yes, but not unconscious when attacked. At least Kaylee wasn't. And neither were Xana and Ethan. Only unconfirmed sleeper is Maddie now.
So sorry for all of these kids and their families and friends. Xana all of you will be remembered not just in America but all over the world. I am in Australia and many people I know are following this awful case. We all want to see justice done. From me personally I send so much love sweetheart and I feel so proud of you for putting up a fight. So brave. Lots of love from Australia.❤❤
Gidday Mate Aussie here😇 yes Ive been following too, its so disturbing
Im so glad they have someone in custody
This particular crime gave me chills, poor kids just starting out in life😖
Send❤to the Families
Uh, she's not reading your post.
Also Xana's mother is arrested in Spokane Washington for trespassing.
If your fingers are shopped off - wouldn't you scream loud enough that Dylan hears it ?
@@TheNewsAnchorYouTrust What does her mother's charges have to do with this?
That poor girl. But you know what, she died a fighter and honestly a hero in my book.
My book too!
My mom always said if I go down, I better go down fighting.
💯💯💯 RIP Xana. 🕊
Indeed. RIP Sweet angels!
I really believe in resurrection here on this but under God's Kingdom. If I'm going be faithful till the end I'm might see many of those beautiful people that list their precious life's for this nonsense.. it's terrible that many bad people do not like to be close to Creator just stick to the evil one and harming peaceful families
The more we come to know about this case, the more horrific it gets. The killer sounds so ruthless and devilish. How can a human being inflict such horror on another human.
we haven't come to know nothing but CONFLICTING statements. Only thing believable is top floor got attacked 1st , then second floor, and that X fought as much as she could.
I believe someone who does this sort of thing is possessed by Satan himself. Mark 5 King James Version
Humans hit the highest of highs and lowest of lows of all animal's behavior
@@AJFresh69 that's a jaundiced view. Maybe most all horses and some serv dogs hit even a higher high than most of the human race.
And a serial killer may well hit lower than the worst dog or horse..;(
Not human…Satan in the flesh
These kids went through pure horror. I couldn't imagine how terrified they had to have been. It takes a real monster to do this kind of evil.
💔 😢
I can’t even imagine the terror she felt. Seeing her boyfriend drop to the floor and then having to fight so hard for her life. It’s just so sad
Then came Dylan who claims not to have heard anything other than a "cry" and "I'll help you" from Xana and Ethan's room. I hope they don't let Dylan get away.
@@aikapalis4219 stop blaming her not all details are out & Dylan wasn’t the only survivor what did Bethany hear? Still a lot to learn
You know she definitely had plenty of time to SCREAMMMMM for her life when E was attacked in her presence. So DM is a lying piece of ...work. and completely evil for not calling 911! I'm sure even E had time to make noise and the struggle had to have made enough NOISE in that hallway for frikin DM! Pisses me off!
Its infuriating. To many of us. Because it was so unnecessary!
@@es4242 we’re you there??
Can't even imagine what these poor kids went through...Xana sweetheart you fought and you fought good. RIP sweetheart 😢 💔 😞
It's amazing to see how hard that girl fought for her life... I just can't imagine what she went through. What all of them went through...very sad. I hope that POS loser gets what he deserves.
No matter what he gets, even if he gets the death penalty, it won't be what he deserves. Being executed is a lot more humane than dying a horrific death like these young adults did.
It's not amazing it's fairly typical. Instinct to fight for one's life
@@H3yItzKevin now that’s just plain disrespectful! Shame on u mister! 🤣😂
If you say so, Brian?
@@citizendame6329 aww, do you feel better now? Did it help your poor, low seIf esteem to try disputing a basic compliment about a m*rdererd girI? Lol. Get well.
They said she was full of life…. When you’re that full of life you’re not going down without a fight…so sad these kids and their families are going through this 😞
Love you Xana. Thank you for fighting so hard. IF IF IF TRUE you likely ruined Brian's night and made him leave right away - saving the lives of your remaining roommates. Going through the trauma of hearing all your friends murdered and seen your boyfriend murdered right in front of you only to realize you're trapped like a rat and have nowhere to go and you're next - the fact that this girl went ham enough to put an end to the conflict altogether is incredible and so brave and says so much about her and who she was as a person
My heart literally hurts 💔💔
I wish I could swooped in and saved u 😔
!!!!!!!!!
Well said. These babies were tough. They were smart. I hope their poor families know that we wont forget them.
❤❤❤❤
YES!!!!
awesome
She was so heartbroken seeing someone she loved gone and knowing she was prob going to die. This all just kills my heart.
@@Maripossa909
I don't think she saw all of them, but she definitely heard it. This was not a peaceful or quiet murder how did everyone else not hear all the commotion surely there were screams. 😢
@@Maripossa909 only E. she wasn't present in top floor to see the 2 girls get deleted.
@@GingerNinja1 DM is deaf and dumb, not calling 911 immediately...oh wait, i forgot she had BRAIN FREEZE.
She probably didn’t care and she was On drugs
@@GingerNinja1 yeah I forgot about that
I don’t think the coroner or Police wants to let everyone know the true horror of this crime.
I think so too :(
They can not tell too much especially in the beginning of the crime, they want to build a good conviction, so I understand LE for not telling the public or family , this world is so screw up , stop 🛑 the killing and get HELP PLEASE!!! it affects me and I don't know these innocent people, just STOP KILLING AND GET HELP, PLEASE!!! Idaho 4 will never be forgotten, RIP beautiful souls,JUSTICE IS ON ITS WAY , LOVE YOU KIDS 💘😍 parents hang in there, LoVE YOU ALL , I JUST WANT PEACE, ✌️✌️✌️
Only for legal reasons. It'll ALL come out. Trust me. It always does.
MARY ANN: Good point, and I agree. Yet we must steel ourselves that once this gets into the courtroom, as tough as it will be, every detail of horror will be known. My hope now is that he will not plead out to avoid his trial.
People were mad that the coroner shared "so much" but it sounds like she was actually holding back a LOT.
The bravery this girl showed .. fought for her life till the end ..
Heartbreaking. How could this monster do such things to these kids? 😢 Hearing about the wounds on her hands…burst into tears thinking about the horror she felt in her final moments. Poor sweet girl. Praying you’re at peace. Justice is coming to you & your friends soon❤
Ashleigh, the coroner hesitated before saying “yes” when you asked her if they were found in beds. You didn’t ask if ALL of them were in beds. So by saying yes, she wasn’t lying if someone was actually on the floor.
And she likely hesitated to verify if saying yes would be a lie and/or in line with what the police wanted the public’s to know at that point.
Agreed!
@Sunflowers, I agree.
I totally agree.
Yep noticed that also … Ethan could have been hurt at the door and stumbled back to the bed and passed away there, but then again she never said ALL of them
That's what I thought.
I'm a bereaved mom of a teenager and my beautiful boy suffered catastrophic injuries, he was knocked down by a car. Yet, I can't even begin to imagine how the families of these 4 beautiful kids feel, knowing what their kids suffered 💔 sending them so much love from Ireland and I'm hoping and praying that pos is in solitary confinement for the rest of his patethic life
Grace, I'm so sorry this has happened to you ⚘⚘⚘
I am so sorry for your terrible loss of your boy.
He needs to be quickly put to death not a long drawn out 5 or 10yrs on death row. There is nothing that can bring these families any true peace but that could maybe help start the healing
So sorry for your loss 😞
I am so sorry for your loss. I can't imagine how terribly heartbreaking it is to lose a child.
So heartbreaking RIP Xana, Ethan, Maddie and Kaylee💔
Damn one minute you’re on tiktok eating your doordash order and the next your boyfriend gets brutally murdered in front of you and you’re next. I just can’t imagine the terror they must’ve felt omg
Watch. Out. China. Cell. Phone. And. Corp. Media. Both. Needs. To. Be. Stopped nnow
Unimaginable 😢
When I heard the reporter say that Xana fought back so much to the point where her fingers were almost severed off from grabbing at the knife.. I unconsciously put my hand over my mouth because it’s so shocking to hear details like these. We truly have no clue what it’s like to be in a position like that… terrifying.
How painful and horrifying.
I did too.
I think this is why Brian left the other roommates alive. I think he was targeting the entire house but Xana fought back so hard that she scared him away/tired him out before he got to the others.
There’s a lot of spin on this interpretation of evidence, assuming the story is true. The first and foremost question is why the leak? Unless it’s intentional, done for some mysterious reason by LE, is it worth risking your job and a contempt of court ruling? Is there so much money available that an investigator would risk it?
@@jimbrown9817 Really small town & police dept. I imagine, w/in 24 hrs, 100% of the dept knew many details. Not long after, the victims family as well. Just my fair chance guess, but say: 30%+ told someone - friend, confidante, spouse, etc. Then, 40%+ of them pass it on (further removed, greater probability - another guess.) Repeat... can see how quickly info gets out. Also Important to note: it increases the likelihood of getting misconstrued as well!✌️
I feel so bad for Xana, as someone who had a mother in the same position as hers, it’s so freeing to finally go and live your own life away from the drama, then to get brutally murdered right after getting out of that situation is so tragic. She was probably just finding her happiness and all hope gets ripped away, RIP Xana. You deserved better
she was raised by her dad
@@nikkimclay5474 yeah so was I, doesn’t change shit
@@nikkimclay5474 Raised by her dad or not, it was still sad that her mother was in that position.
@@jillian9183 as a child psych I believe it does change shit
@@odessa72 sure was sad especially as shes still an addict but she had a great dad & paternal aunt, which many kids dont get, by all means Xana was a thriving & successful young woman.
You say that this is in “direct conflict” but the arrest affidavit literally says that Xana was on the floor and Ethan was “also in in the room”. Based off that I knew right away that he was not in the bed either. In the audio played here the coroner says “yes” to victims being found in their beds but she wasn’t asked if ALL the victims were found in their beds. Also, as for Ethan being slashed, I just want to point out that in the PCA the description of Ethan’s injuries were different than the rest of the victims. Instead of saying he had visible stab wounds the PCA referred to the medical examiner and said his wounds were later determined to be caused by “sharp-force injuries”.
Also, a puncture wound to the neck could be fatal if the jugular is hit.
Ethan was in bed, Xana on the floor inside the room.
@@bewell6019 The arrest affidavit says Maddie and Kaylee were found in a single bed. Like I said Xana was found on the floor and “also in the room was a male, later identified as Ethan Chapin”.
@@bewell6019 They literally say in this video that he was in the doorway.
@@curtf9813 Maddie was in bed under the covers and Kaylee on top of that bed. She was alerted to Maddie being murdered, closed Murphy in her room and went to help screamed and fought but was killed, falling/pushed onto Maddie's same bed.
Ethan goes out to investigate and is not armed at that point, but checking wtf is going on. He retreats quickly to the room to find anything, maybe a pillow ffs. Then gets killed on the bed. Xana was further inside the room and hears Ethan screaming for her to run out now! As she does, BK is able to reach and kill her too, as she collapses to the floor near the door still inside her room (though visible from the bathroom too).
They were killed in November, not October.
That’s “News Nation’s Fact-Driven, Unbiased Coverage”. 😂
Yep, October is in "direct conflict" with what the police reports say.
October. November. Same thing. They both in the fall am right next to one another lol
@@jaymesnin Well if Ashleigh is going to criticize the coroner for what she believes is: "in direct conflict" from the more recent report... you'd think she herself would at least get the correct month right of when the murders took place.
Came here to see if anyone else caught that 😂
What unimaginable bravery. I hope she clawed, and spat, and bit, and scratched him to ribbons, knowing she couldn't overpower him physically, she could overpower him legally by making sure his DNA was on her and around that house. What a little fire cracker 💔 😔
I doubt it. He was covered head to toe - mask, gloves, thick winter clothing.
What a ridiculous comment. Anyone would claw their way out of a single knife fight. It's not bravery its instinct. She likely wasn't thinking of leaving her DNA on him, only surviving. Quit romantacizing murder cases.
You're absolutely right, your comment was ridiculous yet you felt compelled to leave it anyway. Boring! Now, I'll allow you to have the final word, and then you can go and spread your misery elsewhere 😏
@@openorwap5412 yeah, keep walking because you know you're wrong.
She wasn't thinking about DNA and she certainly wasn't thinking that she should spread it around, knowing she couldn't overpower the murderer. She was fighting for her life. Period. When confronted with a knife-wielding maniac dressed in all black in your home in the middle of the night, you fight. She likely couldn't run and was cornered by him. She would have been in a state of terror with her adrenaline pumping. Cuts on the hands from grabbing at the knife is something found in victims of stabbing murders. It is a common reflex to grab for the weapon that your assailant is using, even though it will only hurt you to grab at a blade with your bare hand. I'm sure Xana did everything she could to survive. I feel so bad for her and her friends. It's heartbreaking. But let's not make a superhero storyline up about this horror. Xana wasn't trying to spread her DNA. She was trying to live.
If this is true, it just goes to show how incredibly brave and strong Xana was to fight against this monster. And her battle was heroic enough that she saved the lives of the two surviving roommates. 💗 The fact that these four incredible young adults with so much more to give to the world and make our world a better place had their lives so ruthlessly and heinously taken from them far too soon is beyond heartbreaking. I really hope that Xana, Ethan, Maddie, and Kaylee receive the justice that they deserve. 💞
If “ALL” is true too bad the surviving rm mates didn’t show some of the same strength and bravery
Its instinct anyone getting stabbed or about to and cornered is gona fight! Even a coward is not gona just accept it with no resistance. However , a coward would hear it and realize whats possibly going on and hide till he's gone . He either purposelessly left survivers or didn't know they was there . I doubt her fight made him leave any quicker... Thats my opinion tho. We all have an opinon
Imagine being stabbed and not fighting back.
You’re just going to let someone stab you over and over and just do nothing ?
That has to be incredibly rare.
@@judithgzlz7013 i wonder if the roommates have called 911 and ambulance, would some of them would survive???
I'm sure they ALL fought back hard, not just Xana. Remember Xana was the last to be killed. By the time the killer got to Xana, he had killed three other people.
Initially when this tragedy happened it was said that Ethan was in the hallway near Xana's room. They would be the last victims unfortunately. From what I understand this was a horrific crime.
I really don't want to know about how bad it was. There are many videos that have already gave several accounts of what happened. My heart goes out to the victims and their parents. It's heartbreaking!
There was a report early on that Ethan was in the hallway. I guess we're just going to have to wait until the trial for the correct and full details of what happened.
I've heard about this. Do you remember anything else mentioned from that report?
@@honhae2025 it was locals saying he was found out of bed and in the hallway. That was all.
Banfield never said Ethan was FOUND in the doorway. She discussed how it’s possible the attack STARTED in the doorway and he was pushed into the room.
@@Missundaztood-jc6qg it was one of the first rumors out of this case, I remember. The report did say that Xana was the first one found but did not detail her location.
Well looks like maybe someone was on the bed. The blood dripped down the side of the foundation of the house.
Ethan was probably thinking he needed to help the other girls upstairs after hearing a strange commotion (the reason he was in the doorway) and didn’t know if the attacker was still in the house and also conflicted and scared to leave Xana alone in the room and so then being confused and hesitant without a split-second plan, he was attacked in the dark. So sad. RIP
Or he could have been on his way to the bathroom to take a piss after a heavy night of drinking. Jesus, you people just assume shit and make up wild stories in your own heads.
If that's true than the surviving girl in the same floor would be even more sus
@@irenesara455 Just stop.
I heard rumors somewhere online that one victim was found in the doorway a long time ago. Poor Xana, it seems so much worse for her. Death penalty!
This is heartbreaking. As a mother of a college student, this is just horrifying to think about. RIP, sweet girl.
I can imagine there was a lot of noise and screams if xana fought that hard. Seems like the roommates would have known there was something terrible happening. I hope the truth comes out
and so.... now the accusations are starting again are they mary m. What does m stand for ? MOPHEAD perhaps!.
I truly want to give them the benefit of the doubt but you wouldn’t imagine an attack like this would be quiet by any means to an otherwise ‘silent’ sleeping household
@@jessice293 right, especially if ur bedroom is right below theirs. It sounds like he started in the top floor and attacked kaylee and maddie then maybe thats why ethan was in the hallway because him amd zana heard the commotion and he was going to see what was going on but got attacked next. Then that may have been when Xana was whimpering out of fear when he was coming at her and she may have been trying to get away from her which is why he tried to convince her that he was "trying to help" her. Ughh i wish this was just a night mare. But i really hope this man pays dearly for what he did.
@@Insertcatchienamehere That's also how I pictured it.
How can a camera from another house pick up a whimper, the dog barking and a loud thud but the roommates heard nothing? I'm not buying it.
I really feel they were trying to keep some of those details private as a sort of 'things only the killer would know' type of situation...Also, If Xana fought back that hard she HAD to of made some noise..something..especially because she probably saw Ethan being mxrdered 💔
the affidavid confirms the witness heard crying from her room.
Dumb question. Why doesn't Xana get off of Tik Tok and call 9-1-1?
@Abdou Touzani 'Thought' she heard crying...It apparently wasn't loud enough or concerning enough to the roommate...I Would think if she was fighting for her life, possibly saw her man being kxlled...there would of been a lot more than 'thought she heard crying' going on..ya know!? It's all so devastating 😔
@@orangehoof I’m sure she was in shock & it probably happened so fast. This is tragic and I feel so sad that she saw Ethan being attacked before she passed away. 🙏🏻
@@orangehoof she probably didn’t have time and probably most likely wasn’t Evan on tik-tok. Like they say!!
An eye for an eye. A tooth for a tooth is what the killer deserves (or killers). The more I learn about this case, the deeper the pain and sorrow I feel for Kaylee, Madison, Xana and Ethan. My prayers are with them and their families. I am in Europe. 🙏💔
How scary seeing your boyfriend getting attacked and stabbed and killed in front of you in your room and you have no where to go can't leave the room since they are in the doorway and then to know you are going to be next and have to fight like hell to try to get away but can't get away, omg like a horror movie this is devastating God bless her and all those poor innocent kids in that house. I hope and pray their families get justice this killer needs fry.
Ethan got up to protect her-absolutely heartbreaking! 💔💔
Yes
Remember, they'd just received food at 4 a.m. So if he, killer, (I refuse to use his given name) came in shortly after 4 he just missed the delivery guy(how lucky for him), went immediately upstairs and murdered the girls , Ethan and Xana must have heard THEIR crys, and Ethan steps out just as killer is leaving, so that's when he killed them. Now just when did the other roommate see him? Before or after he killed E &X? Her room was right across the way! Will we ever know a'll of the horrors they all went through
Poor Xana, OMG listening to the details, the horror those poor kids went thru, I cry for these 4 Beautiful kids RIP ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Thank you for sharing this with us. It’s so sad to think what these kids went through.
thank you ? why the hell do we need to know this ? imagine their families hearing this ?
@@nikkimclay5474 thank you! My thoughts exactly.
@@amandab806 its shocking isnt it, beyond humane
🤢
My heart just breaks for these beautiful young kids with their whole lives ahead of them as well as their families. There is so much speculation and disagreements regarding this case but the one thing we can all agree on is that these kids and their families deserve justice for this senseless act. ❤️🙏❤️
this makes me sick. i’m so anxious to see these kids get justice
The murders of these kids is truly devastating and awful .it's unbelievable how savagely they were attacked. The person who did this needs to be given the death sentence. I feel so sad and upset for the victims it makes me tear up , I wish that I could turn back time and save them all .I'm from England 🇬🇧 and I have followed this case closely. My deepest sympathy and prayers go out to the family's and friends of the victims .
It's obvious with the long pure from the coroner she didn't want to give too much info away
Understandable. But I'm quite tired of all the lying from authorities in this case. Say 'no comment' instead of lying. They were not all found in beds according to the PCA.
zana said someone's here,ethan went to go into hallway and was attacked
She probably shouldn't have done an interview
Dear God. Bless them, all 4. And the parents and families.
I felt sick to my stomach just imagining what she and all of them went thru 😓.
She fought back and the roommate heard none of this? Something’s up with that roommate. & she didn’t call police until much much later even after seeing blood literally everywhere. Why are they not investigating her more?
Why wouldn’t ANYONE being stabbed to death fight back?
God those poor kids
Incredibly sad and praying daily for the families of these beautiful kids. Can't wait until justice is served
They were party girls.
They lived a dangerous lifestyle.
@@BERNARDO712
They may have been party girls but being so didn't necessarily attract this sicko killer to them. Most kids do party in college. They in no way are responsible for what happened to them. These days it's dangerous to go to McDonald's for an ice cream cone. One never knows when or where a mass murderer might strike. And I hardly would call going out to McDonald's a dangerous life style.
Never will have justice or closure, unfortunately this is a life sentence to the families 😒
@@BERNARDO712
Party girls...
I suppose your the one person on Earth, that never
ever attended a party or parties ??
If you & I attended a party or many parties..
What does that make us??
A party boy..
And...
A party girl ??
I THINK NOT..!!
So...
If we were SLAUGHTERED at home, where parties took place..
I'm guessing, you'd think it'd make your MOTHER feel really great, reading some IDIOT called her DEAD child a party boy,
PLUS..He pretty much deserved it.
It doesn't sound so Kool now, does it ?!!
NOPE !!
Bless these kids and their loved ones ❤
Kaylee and Maddy may have been sleeping but, Xana and Ethan had food delivered 6 mins before that monster went in the house. There's no way they were asleep. He probably heard Brian with Kaylee and Maddy and opened the door to see what was going on. No matter how it happened it's absolutely disturbing and utterly heartbreaking what those beautiful angels went through. They should put Brian under the jail and do to him what he did to those kids. Maybe big bubba will get a hold of him in the prison. The world would be better off without him.
All these beautiful kids had so much life left to live! It literally makes me sick to my stomach, that their life was taken so brutally by such a monster!! Continued prayers for comfort & strength to all the families! 🙏🙏🙏
This is still so horrifying to me. RIP sweet kids.
They were killed November 13, not in October as she stated.
Correct, 11-22. Address: 1122 is what caught my attention
Good for you Xana. Always fight.
This just keeps getting sadder and sadder. 😢
Kenodle...your the queen!!!!! X
🩷💖🩷🩷
Who knows what happened until it’s officially revealed at trial at this point? I feel so bad for them.
That is deeply sad...the 👿 was in that house. It's so unreal and heartbreaking. What a horrible way to die...it's more and more disturbing. Those poor kids...I hope they get total justice and he gets what he deserves...as they rest in peace as they will.🙏💔
You mean bryan kohberger was in that house
Justice would be just a grain of respite for what the loved ones are going through. The horror this man has subjected hundreds of loved ones and also the community at large is immeasurable. What an EGO to want to be so famous for such an atrocity. And he's done it. Everyone is talking about this. I just can't get over the surrealness of the 4 young people's murders. They went to bed and now they are gone.
My love and compassion to all affected.🧡🕊️🙏
Oh my God 🙏🙏🙏... Xana you are a HERO.. not only did you fight back, you fought back against a 6ft tall stranger, that broke into your home.. attacked and killed your bf right in front of you, then watched, in complete shock and horror knowing you were gonna to be next.. as he came at you with that large intimidating weapon 😭💔
@Mimi ty, it's so freaking sad and unfair 💔
That coroner is the same one that said none of the victims'suffered because it happened so fast.
Well not not for Xana.
Having her fingers nearly severed due to putting her hands up to block the knife wielding at her, says a lot.
She definitely suffered, and not just physically.
Imagine the terror of having to witness your boyfriend being slashed & stabbed to death right infront of your eyes and her knowing she was next?!!!
Xana was truly heroic in my eyes!!
She bravely stood up to the monster lurking around.
Poor babies 😥💔
R.I.P. Xana, Ethan, Madison and Kaylee 🙏🏻💔🕊️❤️💐🤍😢
This is so sad to hear😢
@@bridget999 I agree, It certainly is 😢💔
@@Sean_B_ yes very sad but who are these sources the information came from? Can we believe this? I don't know.
@@tami.1111 She says sources with knowledge of the investigation, I believe, but she didn’t say who or which sources, so I don’t know unfortunately.
I bet she was giving a general answer like yes (some) were in their beds. Unfortunately bc there was 4 people it doesn’t mean it’s untrue as much as her language might have been imprecise. I think this sounds valid
Exactly.
Yes!! Thank you!
Do you really think it's wise to be posting information before the jury is selected? And information from anonymous sources that aren't consistent. Why would you put this information on blast when it could damage the case?!?!
It sickens all of us who did not even know the poor victims......imagine the pain of the people who knew them! So damn horrifying. The only punishment worse than the death sentence for this murderer is hell for eternity, which awaits him.
I would like to know what the two people that survive the attack how they survived. Did they hear screaming and why did they wait so long to call the police or medical attention for the people that had been attacked?
Yet the remaining surviving roomates didn’t hear screaming ? I find that hard to believe
Exactly! But nobody here appears to even get that! It's INCREDIBLE. Makes me sad and dumbfounded!
@@mirosderegil exactly 💯 😢😢😢
There was the talking, dog bark, SCUFFLE, THUD TO THE FLOOR and WHIMPER sounds... All heard many feet away across the parking lot on the neighbors security camera! It was heard in the house by any survivor too.
If you think Xana didn’t scream while having a knife cut her fingers, while she is defending herself, and just seen her bf get his mf neck slashed, you’re naive as hell.
The affidavit doesn’t say “DM didn’t hear screams.” It lists a few things she heard and saw, but there will inevitably be more to the story that comes out at trial. Also real life is not always like horror films where people scream bloody murder at the top of their lungs. Sometimes people go into shock or just start fighting back or cry or have other responses. We have to wait until trial to get the full picture.
Poor kids omg 😲 rot in jail Bryan
No. D_eath penalty. I dont want my tax money going to feed him. That or let him starve. Idc
How did the other roommates NOT WAKE UP!!!!!!!!!
She is a LIAR
One thing about the timeline that always gets me, is the fact that Xana had ordered DoorDash and it was delivered minutes before they died.
Wondering if maybe the door got left unlocked from them getting the food, OR if the killer snuck in somehow at the same time as DoorDash using that as a distraction while getting in from through the back door somehow?
It was a 'no contact' delivery. The driver wasn't met at the door, they just left the food.
Nah… he was already IN the house prior to 4 am, when DoorDash dropped off food. I think he was either already there lying in wait when the kids came home from their outings OR he snuck in once they were all home and in their rooms - very likely at least one door or sliding glass door was left unlocked. The UnSub had a plan and went with it. Hopefully an actual timeline will come to fruition during a trial.
@@adeleferguson663 no he wasn’t if you read the affidavit they have him on surveillance at 4:04 am still driving. And it says that he left through the sliding glass door on the second floor so I’m assuming that’s how he entered as well.
@@adeleferguson663 UnSub? You must watch a lot of Criminal Minds. Anyway, the Sub is certainly no longer Un.
@@allendracabal0819 , while I agree with the general consensus that the guy that has been arrested may very well be the guilty party, I also agree with hearing all the undisputed proof as to why he is THE ONE who actually committed these crimes. In this world we now live in where we are all tracked in some manner or another, one would think the average joe would have at least some “clue” that his moves, calls, locations, can be tracked. BK was a criminology student working towards a doctorate (or masters?). Either way, he cannot be an imbecile to get to that point. IF he is the Un, then he’s either a lot dumber than the average person OR had some psychotic disorder that he hid for many years. This crime makes zero sense. Why that house? Why those girls? - poor Ethan was just in the wrong place at the worst time. I agree it looks bad for this guy. He was in the same area, was allegedly seen by others on that campus when that was not the college he attended, found the girls on their Instagram and actually messaged one a few times. How stalker-ish is that weirdness? It’s going to be nearly impossible to find a jury of this guys peers who has zero clue as to what’s been said and/or speculated on. His lawyers will be busy trying to get him freed on technicality.
This has been pretty clear to me since we heard D's statements. She heard "There's somebody here" (maybe just the uber eats driver for Xana?) She thought she heard kaylee playing with her dog. (This was where Bryan started. My opinion is with Maddie first which is why Kaylee had worse wounds, she had a little more time to fight) Then she heard crying. (This was Xana in the corner of her room witnessing Ethan being killed in the doorway) When asked if D was on the 2nd floor, an official said "yes, initially" So I think after D witnessed Bryan leaving (from Xana's room to the back sliding doors) she locked herself in her room & began texting the others. When only Bethany answered, D decided to run down to be with her for the rest of the night. Maybe it was one of those moments where it's dark, you're scared, & she just ran as fast as she could to and down the stairs with B. Then they're together, kinda scared but just assuming since everything was quiet & nobody else was answering that everything was fine, that guy was just someone's friend, and everyone must be asleep. They slept until like 11 because they were COLLEGE kids who were up late most likely drinking & didn't assume a quadruple homicide just happened above them. Then when morning came, everything was quiet still. They go up the stairs, look to the right and see Ethan laying in the doorway. They don't go closer bc they remember the weirdness of the night before so they call Ethan's brother to come check it out thinking he's just passed out. Then mayhem from there. Idk if it's true someone ran out and passed out and that was the unconscious person or if they were referring to Ethan. Someone said they were in so much shock all they could say was "dead"
And I don't think the coroner had conflicting statements. Just answering vaguely. When she said they were in their beds, she just meant bedrooms. And I think she described the wounds accurately, just less gruesomely.
I agree with you! That's what I have been saying since I heard Dylans statement.
Sounds like that’s probably how it happened. You explained it well. RIP Kaylee, Maddie, Xana, Ethan 😢🙏🏼💐
The one who passed out was one of the surviving victims, they ran out the house and were hyperventilating and the 911 operator heard it over the phone so they sent cops
That makes sense to me and I imagine it was a while before she left her bedroom. In one of the interviews with Kaylee’s dad he was asked about Dylan. He said people need to leave her alone and then he said no one should have to see what they saw. He didn’t elaborate and didn’t answer any more questions. From that comment I took it to mean the two survivors found them later that morning. Most likely they ran outside and that’s when 911 was called. Honestly can’t imagine anyone staying inside after that. I’d have run too.
Just heart wrenching
OMG! Go Xana!!! I think Ethan 100 got up and went to the door to answer him and he was incapacitated. Makes sense.
If he would have knocked on Xanas door, DM would have heard that.
@@outoftime7740 You think? Apparently she can't hear too well at all. I'm sure Xana screamed as loud as she could watching BK kill stab her Ethan.
@@boycee1 You don't know that. If Xana screamed as loud as she could. Obviously she didn't. Bethany heard nothing. So stop punishing DM for seeing him.
I believe Bryan targeted Madison and Kaylee. I think Ethan and Xana were woken up during the process. Ethan did what any man would do and went to check it out and upon leaving the room Ethan was met with Bryan and was probably killed very quickly. Xana on the other hand according to this information suffered. I feel so absolutely sick to my stomach hearing how she fought for her life. But I also just feel so proud of her that she was so brave to face their killer head on. Prayers to these poor students and their families.
And she didn't scream? And the silent witness heard just little noises. I call BS
Absolutely horrific. Justice for Xana, Ethan, Maddie and Kaylee❤
It wasn't in October, it was November when they were murdered
I was thinking the same thing
The unbelievable terror of it all. I just cannot even imagine. My brain won’t even allow for me to try. This entire case has rocked us all to our cores.
This is just heartbreaking 🥺 he probably heard something went to go check it out. Xana told him to be careful and then …. She saw someone attack her bf. And …. Gosh I had a feeling this is what happened. Even though obviously the coroner said something different. Someone had to have tried to fight him off. They probably all tried.
If only someone would have called 911!
I wonder if he came in the house went to Kaylees room first, she wasn’t in there so he went into Maddie’s room. Killed them both. Xana said to Ethan ‘There’s someone here’ so Ethan went out of the room to check just as he was coming downstairs to leave. Saw that Ethan had seen him, so launched at him and slit his throat. Ethan fell in the room on the bed, Xana realized and started to cry. Then he went into the bedroom and said ‘Don’t worry I’m going to help you’ perhaps closed the door and then went at Xana. I’m so glad she put up a fight, it’s completely tragic. Then he left but Dylan had opened her door / stood in the dark because of the noise and either he saw her, but was too exhausted to kill again or he was just focusing on leaving at that point and didn’t see her. This whole thing is super scary and upsetting! If you are not safe at home in your own bed, where are you safe?! Also can I just say the coroner/medical examiner was very vague, definitely not clear perhaps she wasn’t allowed to say much at the point of that interview. These young kids and their poor families it’s terrible, so so tragic. I hope justice is served!
Being parents or relatives to hear these news must hurt soo much...Lord give them Peace.
I’ll never get over this
good
?
@@mischaraine1645 I’m not family. I got all of their names tattooed on my back. I’m legally changing my name to kaylee and my middle name to xana. I’m going to name my child Ethan. I’m also moving to moscow and my kids will go to university of Idaho once they graduate high school
@@user-rn5un7kh2p You need to get some mental help. I think you're suffering "vicarious trauma,” which is a type of traumatic stress, from the case.
@@mischaraine1645 yes don’t worry I already gave the dog I had to the pound and bought a doodle just like Murphy
those poor kids.. I am so so sorry for what they went through..
Does anyone else have a dislike for this woman
Never did like her from years ago when Carlie Brucia's murderer was sentenced to death. AB, said, "You have to remember that's someone's daddy, he has daughters. Wtf?
Affadavit said Xana was on the floor. It did not specify for Ethan. Kaylee and Maddie were found on a bed.
@@mischaraine1645 Bingo
I am horrified by these murders. Those poor kids. Xana must have been absolutely terrified. If Bryan did this, he needs the most severe penalty. I hope it was quick and she did not suffer. May they all rest in peace. My heart is broken for their parents.
Oh they all 4 suffered! Xana had her fingers slashed blood had to be all over the place from boxer Bryan and his K-BAR KNIFE.
I don't think they were asleep just yet perhaps on the verge but that first knife attack was enough to wake them up , it makes no sense they were sound asleep while being stabbed multiple times.. Truly heart breaking
Hello. When Kaylee & Maddy called Kaylee's ex over & over. I haven't heard much about why they called. Especially, if it was SO late. When Kaylee made her last call, I think it was close to 4am or so. That would be close to the time she was killed. Anyone, have info. on that?
If Ethan was partially in the door and Xana fought hard, I find it hard to believe no one say or heard anything.
That's what's really confusing because there were survivors that didn't call the police til later that day..how did she not hear this?
Xana exhausted him - likely saved the final two roommates.
This is so so sad we need justice for the victims and family this should have never happened only a very sick individual would do this
If your source info conflicts with police and coroner why report it as news?
What? She should only take news from sources who parrot what the police and coroner say? You seriously think that??? O.M.G...
@dmcdmc, I agree.
This makes sense since Dylan said she heard "there's someone here" that could have possibly been Xana and Ethan was going out to check and Bryan saw them and had to kill them 🥺
Bryan hasn't been found guilty yet. So why are you saying it was him that killed these 4 students.
@@michaelpower4372 it’s called free speech…. 😂
@@bcolleti9448 Free speech! When you have no "proof" it was "Bryan" "kohberger" that killed the 4 students.
@@michaelpower4372 hes clearly guilty. The fact hes taking it to trial with what we already know is a joke. The jury is gonna have to pretend to be delibrating at this point
@@jaymesnin What we know! are you the head investigator. Into the Idaho killings.
She must have been so scared Rest in peace poor girl.. 🙏
This story makes me so sad and mad. Makes you question what evil is in someone do this.
The exact sequence of the murder seems to me to be of little consequence to the outcome. The different versions of the forensic timeline don’t present a second perpetrator. 4 killed by knife by a single assailant.
What kind of world is this that this can happen... how sick are we humans to be able to do this. :(
I agree I've watched dateline some ppl had been killed the same or worse so sad for someone to do this they have to have the devil in them bc a loving and caring person will never do this to another human being. So sad and heart breaking 💔
So brutally disgusting this happened to these beautiful innocent lives
🤯💔😢
How did the survivor say she heard people talking but didn't hear anyone fighting for their life..didn't hear anyone screaming..and then didn't call the police til the next day..
The coroner’s report was purposefully vague . She should have said NOTHING whatsoever .
I have always been scratching my head about how the only male among the victims was not able to tackle the knife-wielding killer. It’s highly likely the stab wound he received in his neck killed him instantly, otherwise, the two victims could have fended off their assailant. It’s my speculation in fact that Xana was not the first to confront her killer when he entered their room.
Well we don’t know the circumstances. Maybe the killer was already pumped in adrenaline, Ethan maybe wasted or something, not full strength trying to fight off a maniac. Maybe the killer was in coca or speed, like, many possibilities why they couldn’t fight him off
@@aClownBaby- He was pumped on something that's for sure. Th freak barely slept
Yes, I think Kohberger got very "lucky" to catch Chapin's neck. The Mount Vernon sports stat page says that Chapin was 6'4 and we can tell he's athletically built. Kohberger is a good 4 inches shorter.
This makes me even sadder, that young girl had a gdf horrific last moments. If BK is guilty (likely IMO) he deserves whatever he gets in prison.
I am picturing him frantically swiping at Ethan's head/neck in a backhand motion when he met him in the doorway... could be totally wrong, just a feeling
I am disgusted by your questions-stab or slash! What difference does it make to you?